Home / Research / List

Ahrefs alternatives: what 100 top SEOs actually mention, and what each one costs

By Bainian17 November 20264 min read13 sources

84 vs 74of 100 top SEOs mention Semrush vs Ahrefs

The short answer

If $129 a month for Ahrefs Lite is too much, start free with Google Search Console and Ahrefs' own free plan for your site. Pay only when you need competitor or link data: Majestic Lite ($49.99) for links, Moz Standard ($99) or Semrush ($199) for a full suite.

  • Among 100 top SEOs, the most mentioned tool is free: Google Search Console (87 people). Semrush comes next (84), then Ahrefs (74).
  • Ahrefs still gets credit for its link data. Charles Floate called it 'the biggest and best link index on the planet' even while he moved away over price.
  • Cheaper tools are fine when they do the job. Katarina Dahlin switched from Semrush to the lesser-known Wincher for exactly that reason.
How this was researched

We counted how many of the 100 SEOs in our library mention each tool anywhere in their public work (articles, posts, transcripts), using exact tool names so ordinary words don't count. A mention is not an endorsement. Quotes come from their own articles and are copied word for word. Prices were read from each tool's official pricing page on 17 November 2026, monthly billing, before tax.

Short version: Ahrefs is still one of the best SEO tools. It is also expensive. The cheapest plan, Lite, costs $129 a month.

So I looked at two things:

  1. Which tools the 100 SEOs in our library actually mention in their own work.
  2. What each alternative costs today, from its official pricing page.

We pay for Ahrefs ourselves (the Standard plan), so this isn’t a “never use Ahrefs” piece. It’s about when you don’t need it.

Which tools top SEOs mention

Out of 100 well-known SEOs, this is how many mention each tool somewhere in their articles, posts or talks:

Tool SEOs who mention it (of 100) Price to start
Google Search Console 87 Free
Semrush 84 $199 a month
Ahrefs 74 $129 a month (free plan for your own site)
Screaming Frog 68 Free up to 500 URLs (per Aleyda Solis, Joe Hall)
Moz Pro 53 $99 a month
Similarweb 52 Free trial
SE Ranking 42 $129 a month
Sitebulb 41 n/a
Majestic 31 $49.99 a month
Ubersuggest 20 n/a
Mangools (KWFinder) 16 n/a
SpyFu 16 n/a

Two things stand out.

  • The most mentioned tool is free. Google Search Console shows how your own site does in Google: which searches, which pages, how many clicks. 87 of 100 top SEOs bring it up.
  • Semrush comes up more than Ahrefs (84 vs 74). Most pros know both.

A mention is not a recommendation. Someone may mention a tool to criticise it. But it tells you which tools working SEOs actually deal with.

What people say about Ahrefs

Ahrefs earned its reputation on link data: the record of which sites link to which. Charles Floate, back in 2016, while saying price was pushing him to other tools:

“from my research Ahrefs still has the biggest and best link index on the planet”

The problem has always been cost. Craig Campbell, in his 2022 roundup:

“But the problem is that not everyone can afford it.”

And Katarina Dahlin (2026) on how she picks tools now:

“I’ve also switched from more expensive tools (like Semrush) to cheaper, less well-known ones (like Wincher) when they do the job just as well.”

The alternatives, by what you need

You only need data about your own site

Start free:

  • Google Search Console. Your real Google searches, clicks and pages. Nothing else is as accurate for your own site.
  • Ahrefs Free. Ahrefs renamed Ahrefs Webmaster Tools to Ahrefs Free. It gives free website analytics, a technical audit and SEO metrics for sites you prove you own.

Most new sites can stop here for months.

You need to see competitors’ keywords

  • Semrush is the one most top SEOs know. Starter costs $199 a month, or $165.17 a month billed yearly. Katarina Dahlin calls it “a good alternative to Ahrefs, especially if the client already uses Semrush”.
  • SE Ranking costs the same as Ahrefs Lite: $129 a month, or $103.20 billed yearly.
  • Moz Pro Standard is the cheapest full suite here: $99 a month, or $79 billed yearly.
  • Google Keyword Planner is free. Ross Hudgens’ team at Siege Media lists it as “Google’s free alternative to Ahrefs” for keyword ideas.
  • Majestic is the specialist. Lite costs $49.99 a month, Pro $99.99. Floate said Majestic gives you “more data for your buck”, though without Ahrefs’ extra tools. Craig Campbell called it “considerably cheaper than others”.

You want something simple and cheap

  • Mangools (which started as KWFinder). Matt Diggity notes it “markets itself as an affordable alternative to Ahrefs and SEMrush”. I couldn’t read its current prices from the official page, so check there.

Prices side by side

All prices are monthly billing, before tax, as shown on each official page on 17 November 2026.

Tool Cheapest plan Per month Billed yearly
Ahrefs Lite $129 up to 17% less
Semrush Starter $199 $165.17
SE Ranking Core $129 $103.20
Moz Pro Standard $99 $79
Majestic Lite $49.99 n/a
Google Search Console Free
Ahrefs Free Free (verified sites)

Prices change often. Always check the official page before you buy.

A simple way to decide

  1. Under a year old, few pages? Use Search Console and Ahrefs Free. Pay nothing.
  2. Need competitor keywords for a few weeks? Rent one month of Semrush, SE Ranking or Moz, do the research, cancel.
  3. Doing link building every week? Pay for link data: Ahrefs if you can, Majestic if you can’t.
  4. Running SEO for clients? A full suite pays for itself. Pick the one your clients already know.

Limits of this evidence

  • Mention counts include any mention, positive or negative, from any year.
  • Several quotes are old: Floate’s is from 2016, Craig Campbell’s from 2022. Tools have changed since.
  • I didn’t test each tool’s data quality for this piece. These are the views of the people quoted, plus today’s prices.

✓ Do this next

Connect Google Search Console and sign up for Ahrefs' free plan for your own site today. Only buy a paid tool when you hit a question these two can't answer, and pick the cheapest tool that answers it.

My takeMost small sites don't need an all-in-one suite in year one. They need their own search data, which is free, and occasional competitor data, which you can rent for a month at a time.

Sources

  1. Ahrefs: Plans and pricingahrefs.com
  2. Ahrefs Free (formerly Ahrefs Webmaster Tools)ahrefs.com
  3. Semrush: SEO and AI search pricingsemrush.com
  4. SE Ranking: Subscription plansseranking.com
  5. Moz Pro: Pricingmoz.com
  6. Majestic: Plans and pricingmajestic.com
  7. Charles Floate: Link building tools (2016)charlesfloate.com
  8. Craig Campbell: Ahrefs alternatives (2022)craigcampbellseo.com
  9. Katarina Dahlin: The best SEO tools I actually use (2026)katarinadahlin.com
  10. Katarina Dahlin: Keyword and competitor analysis (2026)katarinadahlin.com
  11. Matt Diggity: Mangools review (2025)diggitymarketing.com
  12. Aleyda Solis: SEO tools (LearningSEO.io)learningseo.io
  13. Siege Media: Tips to write SEO-friendly content (2024)siegemedia.com

Follow the research on X

The short version of every piece, plus daily notes on SEO and growth.