How top SEOs meet site owners, and how that turns into links
The short answer
None of the top practitioners we read built their network by cold email. They met in small private groups and at events. What they got was mostly tips and deals; links came later, as a side effect.
- Give first. Matt Diggity offers a site owner free keyword research before asking for anything, and says he is almost never turned down.
- Keep a log of everyone you contact, even if nothing comes of it. Charles Floate's log of 100,000+ sites became worth $50,000 to $100,000.
- Swapping links on a schedule breaks Google's rules, even with related sites. Google's John Mueller said so in 2021.
How this was researched
From the X and LinkedIn posts of 19 practitioners, we filtered for link exchange, outreach, relationships, mastermind, community and networking, and read about 230 by engagement. In video transcripts the same terms hit about 300 files; we read the relevant parts of about 45. Plus Glen Allsopp's advanced link building guide and Barry Schwartz's write-up of John Mueller on link exchanges (2021).
None of the practitioners we read built a network by cold-emailing strangers.
Their networks came from three places:
- Small private meetings called masterminds (a few dozen people sharing what really works).
- Private WhatsApp and Telegram groups.
- Running their own podcasts and events.
What the network mostly gives them is tips, deals and introductions. Links come as a side effect.
Where the relationships come from
Masterminds: the part they value most
How Chiang Mai started. According to James Dooley, a group of UK SEOs held meetups and posted photos. Matt Diggity invited them to Thailand. In year one, 26 people met in Chiang Mai. The next year 257 applied, and Diggity turned it into the Chiang Mai SEO conference. The mastermind is still kept to about 60.
What they say about it:
- James Dooley: the real material is shared there, not on stage. He invested in two companies through these meetings.
- Ivana Flynn (2026): what matters is who you know, not how-to tips. If you don’t give, you don’t get.
- Mads Singers has run 100+ masterminds over 12 to 13 years. Hearing other people’s problems often teaches you more than asking your own.
- Craig Campbell: people who call conferences useless are wrong. The value is in the conversations.
Conferences they keep going to
These come up again and again, each with a mastermind attached:
- Chiang Mai SEO, Thailand, usually November.
- SEO Mastery Summit, Ho Chi Minh City, March. 400+ people in 2026.
- The Masterminders, Manchester, June.
- SEO Estonia, Tallinn, June to July.
- Koray’s Holistic SEO Mastermind, Turkey, autumn, invite only.
Ross Hudgens’ tip: host your own small breakfast next to a big conference.
Private groups and paid communities
- James Gregory is in private chat groups of about 100 SEOs who share hundreds of links a day. He sees which kinds of links work in which markets.
- Kasra Dash surveyed 40 SEOs he trusts, all from these groups.
- Paid communities: Charles Floate’s, $329 a month. Kyle Roof’s, $97. Craig Campbell’s, under £100.
- Cyrus Shepard: if the right group doesn’t exist, start one.
Your own podcast or event
Dooley’s podcast has hosted almost the whole practitioner crowd. Dooley and Kasra Dash call it authority by association: be seen often with trusted people, and people trust you.
Carrie Rose says people agree to meet her because they’ve already heard of her.
How they start, and how they keep in touch
Give something useful first
- Matt Diggity: before asking to write for a site, he does keyword research for the owner, shows a term their competitor ranks for, and offers to write that page. He says he’s almost never turned down.
- Charles Floate (2026): build two or three genuinely useful free tools, like calculators, that people want to link to.
The first message
- Matt Diggity (2025): find sites that link to two or more of your competitors. Write to a real person, not contact@.
- John Mueller (Google, 2021): telling a site owner you have content they might like is fine. Agreeing to trade links is not.
Follow up, then follow up less often
Mads Singers: follow up on a schedule, close together at first, then further apart. He once followed up for six months, won the deal, and five or six more after it.
Write everything down
Charles Floate logs every site he contacts, with prices and names, even when he doesn’t buy. Ross Hudgens connects with people on LinkedIn, later suggests a coffee with no pitch, and goes through the list now and then to stay in touch.
Don’t be one of the 600 emails
Carrie Rose was told by a journalist that they get about 600 emails a day and write about 6 stories. The emails that work are specific to what that person actually writes about.
How relationships become links
| Method | How it works | Risk |
|---|---|---|
| Trading links | You link to me, I link to you, directly or through a third site. | Google treats it as a violation once it’s a pattern. |
| Using your own sites as currency | Floate once traded links from about 50 of his own sites for links from real travel bloggers. | Grey area, and in the past. |
| Swapping guest articles | Ken Lyons (2013) swapped about 100 articles a month with bloggers. | Old method. Google has cracked down on mass guest posting since. |
| Swapping “best of” list spots | Put me in your list, I’ll put you in mine. Cyrus Shepard says it seems to work for now. | Expected to be caught eventually. |
| Real business referrals | A realtor linking to the lawyer they actually recommend, and back. | Google accepts this. |
| Press and expert quotes | Keep giving the same journalists stories that fit what they write. | Google accepts this. Hardest to penalise. |
Mueller’s view, as Barry Schwartz put it:
“exchanging a link for a link is against Google’s guidelines but it seems some may think it is not if they are topically relevant.”
Where they disagree
- Trade links or not? Floate publicly says avoid it, but has described doing it for years with his own sites. My read: publicly no, privately some do, never in public swap groups.
- Network for links, or for business? Dooley, Flynn, Kasra Dash and Campbell almost always talk about tips, clients and deals, rarely links.
- Is outreach still worth it? Floate (2025): outreach is dead. Diggity (2025) still teaches it. Hudgens (2026): in a competitive niche there are usually only about 20 placements worth chasing.
The numbers
| Who | What | Number |
|---|---|---|
| Dooley | Chiang Mai mastermind | 26 people in year one, 257 applicants in year two |
| Navneet Kaushal (2026) | Bengaluru AI mastermind | 130+ applicants for 35 seats |
| James Gregory | Private group | About 100 SEOs |
| Floate | His contact log | 100,000+ sites, worth $50,000 to $100,000+ |
| Floate | Buying abandoned blogs | Often $500 |
| Carrie Rose | A journalist’s inbox | About 600 emails a day |
What we did not find: reply rates for messages to site owners, or what one relationship link costs.
What this means for a small team
- Start a contact log today. It’s free and becomes an asset in a year.
- Keep one public identity for years. Reply properly under other people’s posts each week. Share your own data now and then.
- Open by giving. A keyword idea, a small tool, data about their niche.
- Go to one or two events a year that have a mastermind. Talk to the people online first.
Limits of this evidence
- Lots of posts about networking. Few about exactly how a relationship turns into a link.
- Most of the detail on trading links comes from Floate, and much of it is in the past.
- People who sell links (Floate’s PressWhizz, Serpzilla) have a stake in what they say.
✓ Do this next
Start a simple spreadsheet today: person, site, what they want, what you gave, last contact, next contact. Add five people this week whose posts you actually read.
My takeLinks are what a good network leaves behind, not what it's for. Become someone with something to give, then show up where the right people are.
Sources
- Barry Schwartz: Google says link exchanges are against its guidelinesseroundtable.com
- Glen Allsopp: Advanced link building strategiesdetailed.com
- Marie Haynes: Don't fall for small business SEO scamsmariehaynes.com
- Tim Soulo: Reciprocal links study (Ahrefs)ahrefs.com