Home / Research

Every online link building method, ranked for a brand-new site

By Bainian16 November 20266 min read6 sources

17%link rate from 111 outreach emails

The short answer

Expect about 5 links per 100 emails on a new site. Only two approaches really work when nobody knows you: make something worth citing, or fill a gap on someone else's page.

  • Tim Soulo (Ahrefs) got 19 links from 111 emails, and says a new site should expect two to three times worse.
  • Free tools are the best bait. A simple tyre size calculator earned 3,000+ links.
  • Getting into other people's 'best of' lists now helps twice: links from Google, and mentions in ChatGPT answers.
How this was researched

We scanned our whole library of 100 SEOs (articles and video transcripts, key books, Charles Floate's paid material, six paid products, and the X and LinkedIn posts of the core practitioners) with 49 search patterns in parallel, then read the original texts with the most hits for each method, about 45 in full.

There are about 40 ways to get links in our library. They fall into seven groups.

For a new site nobody has heard of, only two groups really work:

  1. Make something people want to cite: a free tool, some data, an original image.
  2. Fill a gap that’s already there: a dead link on someone’s page, a resource list, a “best of” article.

The rest either need a known brand, carry a risk of Google penalties, or Google simply ignores them.

What to expect from outreach

Tim Soulo of Ahrefs, on his own outreach:

“out of 111 emails I managed to land 19 backlinks.”

That’s 17%. He says a new site should expect two to three times worse. Plan on 3 to 6 links per 100 emails.

What people talk about vs what works

Mentions in our library. Popularity is not the same as usefulness.

Method Mentions in articles and videos Note
Digital PR (stories pitched to journalists) 4,926 Most talked about, mostly by agencies
Communities (Reddit, forums, Quora) 2,356 Mostly about traffic, not links
Guest posts 2,314
“Best of” lists 873 Hot again in 2026 because of AI answers
Resource pages 857
Dead link replacement 679
Free tools 96 Rarely discussed, biggest wins

The two most talked-about methods are among the hardest for a new site.

Group A: Make something worth citing

No brand needed. Best first choice.

Free tools and calculators

  • Glen Allsopp cites a simple tyre size calculator (Tiresize.com) that earned 3,000+ links.
  • Patrick Stox (Ahrefs, 2026): some of Ahrefs’ most visited pages are free tools. A tool gets more links if each result has its own shareable page, and if others can embed it.
  • Charles Floate (2026): in his plan to restart from zero, days 31 to 60 are for building two or three useful free tools.

The catch: most calculators earn nothing. Check what links similar tools actually got before you build.

Your own data, or a page of statistics

  • Siege Media: a page collecting ransomware statistics earned 300+ links.
  • Siege’s 2026 study: consumer topics get linked far more. Real estate earned 14.4 links per 10,000 visits. B2B software, 2.5.
  • Fery Kaszoni analysed 568 million Instagram posts, wrote 600 words and sent it to pet journalists. He got top-tier media links.

A statistics page doesn’t need original data. You can collect other people’s numbers.

Original images

Hunter and Kasra Dash put original images on free stock photo sites with credit required. When someone uses one without credit, they ask. 20% to 30% agree to add a link.

Put other people on a list

Write “the 50 people worth following in X” or “best tools for Y”, then tell each person. That gives a new site a real reason to say hello.

Group B: Fill a gap that’s already there

No brand needed. Best first choice.

Link rot means links that now point to pages that no longer exist. According to Patrick Stox’s Ahrefs study, at least 66.5% of links to sites since 2013 are dead.

How it works:

  1. Find pages in your niche that link to a page that’s now gone.
  2. Make a page that covers what the dead one did.
  3. Tell the site owner.

Real rate: Webology sent 250 emails and got 6 links (2.4%).

A new twist from Tim Soulo (2026): Ahrefs’ blog had hundreds of dead pages that other people’s AI articles had linked to, with addresses the AI simply made up. Those made-up links may point at your competitors too. Nobody has tested this yet.

Resource pages

Search Google for inurl:resources plus your topic. Craig Campbell: these are just posts listing tools and guides. Adding you makes their page better.

“Best of” lists and newsletters

  • Offsprout pitched 20 bloggers and got 5 (25%).
  • Tim Soulo (2026): “best X” lists are the page type ChatGPT cites most, 43.8% of the time.
  • Lily Ray (2026) warns: writing your own list with yourself at number one no longer works.

Get on lists other people write.

Group C: Writing to people one by one

No brand needed, but low success for new sites.

Approach Result
Promoting a good article (Tim Soulo) 111 emails, 19 links (17%)
“Skyscraper”: make a better version, then email people linking to the old one (Brian Dean) 160 emails, 17 links (11%)
Skyscraper that failed (relayed by Craig Campbell) 40 hours, zero links
Cold messages after chatting on social first (Amanda Natividad, SparkToro) Reply rate 80%+

Guest posts: Google’s Matt Cutts said in 2014 that writing articles for other sites just for links was over. Glen Allsopp says site owners are flooded with these requests.

Group D: Journalists

Works for new sites, but needs a named expert.

HARO was a service where journalists posted questions and experts answered. It closed at the end of 2024. Siege Media lists 17 replacements, including Qwoted, Featured and Help a B2B Writer.

  • Karl Kangur: beginners got about 10% of answers published, about 25% with practice.
  • Fery Kaszoni: a normal campaign gets 8 to 10 links.

Journalists want a person with expertise. They don’t care how old your site is.

Group E: The basics everyone needs

Profiles on Crunchbase, Product Hunt, LinkedIn, review sites and directories. Charles Floate says Google wants to see 30 to 50 of these before it treats you as real.

Do it once and don’t expect rankings from it. Moz checked 2,678 directories: 20% had been penalised or removed by Google.

Approach What happened Verdict
Scholarship pages for links 10Beasts got a manual penalty Don’t
Free products for reviews Google penalised bloggers in 2016 Fine only if the link is marked “nofollow”
Giveaways and contests Google’s Mueller says to be careful Don’t
Buying links About $200 to $300 for a decent one (Soulo) A business decision
PBNs (private networks of sites you own, built only to link to yourself) Many tutorials exist Don’t

Group G: Only useful once people know your name

  • Unlinked mentions: asking people who mention you to add a link. Needs people to be mentioning you.
  • Patrick Stox’s Ahrefs study: being mentioned by name tracks with showing up in Google’s AI answers more strongly (0.664) than links do (0.326).

My ranking for a site nobody knows yet

Rank Approach What to expect
1 A free tool, then tell people Most get a few links; the best get thousands
2 Get into other people’s lists and newsletters About 25%, and helps with AI answers
3 Replace dead links About 2.4%
4 Resource pages No reliable number
5 A statistics page on a consumer topic Tens to hundreds of links
6 Ask for credit on your original images 20% to 30% agree
7 Answer journalists as a named expert 10%, rising to 25%

Limits of this evidence

  • Mention counts measure how much people talk about a method, not how well it works.
  • Most success rates are single cases, often from people who sell the service.
  • Several numbers are old (Moz 2012 and 2015, Brian Dean). Reply rates have fallen since.

✓ Do this next

Pick one small free tool or data page your niche is missing. Build it, then send it to 20 people who already link to similar pages.

My takeMost link advice is written for brands. A new site has no brand, so its only currency is usefulness. Spend your first month making one thing people want to cite.

Sources

  1. Tim Soulo: How to get backlinks (111 outreach emails)ahrefs.com
  2. Patrick Stox: Ahrefs study on link rotahrefs.com
  3. Tim Soulo: Reciprocal links study (Ahrefs)ahrefs.com
  4. Moz: The broken link building biblemoz.com
  5. Siege Media: HARO alternativessiegemedia.com
  6. Glen Allsopp: Advanced link building strategiesdetailed.com

Follow the research on X

The short version of every piece, plus daily notes on SEO and growth.